
Episode 328
In this episode of the Secure Your Retirement Podcast, Radon and Murs discuss the crucial differences between investing before retirement and investing during retirement, and how your approach to risk, growth, and income changes as you move from the accumulation years to the de-accumulation phase. They break down why the strategies that work in your 30s, 40s, and 50s often need to be adjusted once you reach retirement, especially when protecting retirement savings and managing withdrawal needs.
Listen in to learn about how to adapt your retirement investment strategy using tools like the Three Bucket Strategy and strategic asset allocation in retirement. You’ll also hear why retirement income planning and retirement withdrawal strategy are essential for retiring comfortably while maintaining a growth mindset. Whether you’re 10 years from retirement or already there, this episode will help you refine your retirement savings strategy and create a plan to secure your retirement.
In this episode, find out:
- The key differences in financial planning for retirement during the accumulation and de-accumulation phases.
- How market downturns affect post-retirement investing compared to pre-retirement.
- Why the Three Bucket Strategy helps balance growth and safety for your retirement income planning.
- How asset allocation in retirement can help preserve wealth while still allowing for growth.
- The importance of retirement withdrawal strategy and tax-efficient income planning.
Tweetable Quotes:
- Radon Stancil: “When you lose 50% of your money in retirement, you don’t have decades to make it back—protecting your retirement savings becomes priority number one.”
- Murs Tariq: “The goal isn’t to stop growing your money in retirement, it’s to grow within reason so you can retire comfortably without unnecessary stress.”
Resources:
If you are in or nearing retirement and you want to gain clarity on what questions you should be asking, learn what the biggest retirement myths are, and identify what you can do to achieve peace of mind for your retirement, get started today by requesting our complimentary video course, Four Steps to Secure Your Retirement!
To access the course, simply visit POMWealth.net/podcast.
Here’s the full transcript:
Welcome to secure your retirement podcast, Murs and I are very happy to take some
time to talk to you about a very important topic today and the episode here
today is really talking about investing before retirement and then during retirement
and the differences between that and here’s kind of the thought process
behind it is when I’m younger and I’m in a growth mode and I can
withstand letting my money just sit and grow and I could actually have markets that
maybe you’re volatile doesn’t bother me. In fact, if you’re listening to today and
Let’s say that you’re 60 maybe 65 and you think back to the last time that you
saw Major downturn in the market that would take you back to 2008 Well,
you were quite a bit younger in 2008, So you were probably working feeding your 401k
and whenever that market turned down which by the way from the top to the bottom
fell 58 % You probably Were maybe concerned or perplexed,
but like I got plenty of time left to work. I’m just going to keep feeding it.
And if you did what you should have done back then, you probably fed it even more
because the market was so low. And so, you just put more money in because you knew
you had a long-time horizon. Now if today, you are 6065 and you had that same
scenarios happen, the stress level on that is going to be very, very different. Why?
Well, because if you lose 50 % of your money now, you don’t have those decades to
make it back. And it’s quite detrimental. In fact, we talk about this a lot when
we’re talking to our clients. If I’ve got $100 ,000 and I lose 50%,
how much money do I have? Well, if you’re doing that math with me really quick, it
means you’ve got $50 ,000. Now, if the next year the market did a gangbuster year
and made 50%, are you back to a break even? And the answer is no,
you’re at 75 ,000. So, when you lose money, at the rate of, let’s just call it 50%,
I have to make 100 % rate of return to make it back to a break -even. Not as big
a deal if I’m younger and working and feeding, but if I am closer to or in
retirement, that’s a really big deal. So, we have to really think about risk in a
different perspective than we would when we were in our 40s or 30s or something
like that. So, what we really are talking about today is, what type of things do I
need to think about? What types of shifts do I need to make as I get closer to
or in retirement? It doesn’t mean we’re going to get out of growth. It doesn’t mean
we’re going to stop trying to grow our money, but we might have a different approach
in saying, how much downside risk am I really wanting to be exposed to?
And that’s really the day. So, uh, Merse, I think what we wanted to do is kind of
hop over to your side and kind of talk about the two different phases specifically
when it came to this idea before and during retirement. Yeah. So, two distinct phases
that are talked about quite a bit in our industry, which is pre -retirement and then
post-retirement. And what are the things that you do when it comes to
retirement planning or really in this, in this, in this case investing in pre
-retirement versus post-retirement. So, think of pre -retirement, that is another way to
look at it as your accumulation phase. That is, you’re doing everything you can to
sock away money for this distant ideal of retirement down the road. And hopefully
you start early and you’re starting to save in your 20s and 30s and saving even
better into your 40s and 50s, and you really get the power of compounding growth on
the money that goes into those accounts. And 401(k)s,
IRAs, 457s, 403 (b)s, the list goes on and on of these pre -tax types of retirement
accounts. To me, in a way, they’re just a big funding vehicle with some benefits to
them. thing about the 401(k), the more you put in there, the more it’s going to
reduce your tax bill for the year if you’re using a traditional 401(k).
And it has its own tax things that we have to think about down the road, but it
becomes a massive incentive to put money in there so that we reduce our tax bill,
but it’s really a funding vehicle for retirement, just like an IRA is or any other
retirement based account. And so, like Radon was saying, in our younger years,
as we are trying to accumulate wealth, we can handle some of those ebbs and flows
of the market a lot better because we know we’ve got time ahead of us. And the
phrase of like, think about the 2008 of buying the dip is a real possibility
because we are working and earning and there are times where we have the cash on
hand available to make that decision to say, “Hey, the market’s down 10%, 15%, 50%,
let me dump some more money in there because I know I’ve got time to really
benefit from that.” That changes a little bit when we get into post-retirement or
no longer accumulation, we’re no longer working, earning, and saving, now we are
still, now we are really spending that money. And that’s a bit of a hurdle for
people in some of the meetings that we run, financial plan strategy meetings, and
kind of walking through the financial plan and showing that this year, based off of
the numbers, you’re going to have to withdraw $30 ,000, $40 ,000, $50 ,000 out of the
portfolio, it can be a little bit nerve wracking to say how is that possible and
how is that run rate going to be okay for the next 30-some-odd years? And so
that’s the distribution or the de -accumulation phase of your life where you’re no
longer earning, you’re living off of what you have or what you’ve done to prepare
for retirement. So, in most cases, for most people, it’s going to be you’ve got so
security as a fixed income. Some of you may have a pension, but then it’s really
your investments, whether that’s the 401 (k)s, the IRAs that you’ve built up, maybe
a brokerage account as well, cash in the bank. Maybe you’ve got some rental
properties that are income generating, but that’s all, what have I done to prepare
for retirement?
And so, thinking that through, and here’s the key, I think sometimes the industry
just says, when you retire, you need to be very conservative. We don’t agree with
that. We think that there are ways that you should invest your money in different
types of risk factors and different types of ways so that we pick up
diversification, but in no way are we saying that, “Hey, we need to stop growing.”
Absolutely, we need to continue growing the money, growing that bucket as best as
possible within reason and within the risk that you’re willing to handle. But the
distribution phase is very important, and getting that set up properly is really
what’s going to lead to that comfort and that reliability and that peace of mind
when it comes to retirement. Those are the two. Build that wealth and then
eventually start spending it down. And then maybe we leave some behind to our heirs
as well. So, Radon, let’s talk a little bit about goals people have when it comes
to the pre -retirement side of it and then during retirement and things that we hear
all the time from clients. – Yeah, I mean, if you think about it, if you’re still
working and maybe now let’s talk about maybe your fifties and you’re still working,
the goals usually at this phase are still the same. I mean, you’re trying to max
fund your 401k. You’re doing the catch -up on the 401k. You’re trying to sock away
as much money as you can. You’re probably still growth oriented in your portfolio
because you know you’ve got another decade, really of work, a decade, decade and a
half. And so, you might be starting to think about risk a little bit, but really
you’ve still got enough to say, “No, we’re going to fund this 401 (k) as much as
we can. We’re going to grow it as fast as we can, so we’re willing to take a
little bit of risk because we’ve got that time.” And that’s all great. That’s all
wonderful. Now, as I get into retirement, a couple things change.
When I get to retirement, I’m no longer working. I’m not going to be max funding
the 401 (k), so that’s not going to happen. I’m going to start to think about
preserving my wealth. I usually say to people, our typical client,
our statistical client, if you want to take it, they say this, I would like to
make a decent rate of return and not lose a bunch of money. And that is exactly
what our infrastructure is, is to say, how can we do, how can we avoid major
losses? Now we’ll talk about this a little bit more, and we have a whole episode
on this or topic, but one of the ways we do this is with a three-bucket strategy.
Bucket number one is my cash. Bucket number two is my income and safety bucket. And
then bucket number three is still my growth bucket. So, the only thing I did is
instead of just leaving everything in the growth bucket, I moved some over into my
income safety bucket because now in retirement, I’m going to need some safety and
I’m going to need some income. So, if I’ve got enough money coming in on my income
safety bucket, I can allow some volatility on my growth bucket. It just keeps the
emotional roller coaster out of our head, right? So, we’re not that worried. Another
thing that we have to think about during retirement are required minimum
distributions. Now, that for most people, if you are in your 50s or early 60s right
now, that’s going to be age 75. So, you’ve got some time and that gives you time
to start planning. And some of the things you might want to start thinking about
there is how do I get money from a tax deferred scenario to a tax -free scenario,
again, kind of a part of this whole investment strategy of what I want to make
sure, I think through. I also want to think about where do I want to take money
from? For decades and decades, I worked, and I saved money and now I’m going to be
in retirement and so now I’ve got to start taking money. Do I take that from my
Roth IRA? Do I take it from my traditional IRA? Do I take it from my individual
or joint account? Do I take it from the bank? Well, there are good strategies to
think about when it comes to that. And one of the things that we provide for our
clients are income strategies. What is the best way to take income to make ourselves
tax -efficient, to deal with risk? So, those are all things that you’ve got to think
through when it comes to this, the daring retirement element of things. Now, there
is the investment side and we want to talk a little bit more about that. We’ll
kind of talk a little bit more about the buckets as well. But we’ve got two topics
we want to kind of move into here. Here really is risk management and then
allocation really between those buckets. Yep. So, let’s talk about the phrase asset
allocation. That’s a term that’s used a lot in our in our world. And so, but it
can mean a bunch of different things. But in general, it’s saying how are we
distributing the assets to in our portfolio, right? So, a simple way to look at it,
the most commonly known model portfolio is that 60 /40 asset allocation,
60 % towards equities, 40 % towards bonds or fixed income, and that’s been one of
the more popular ones. That one has actually been, had a lot of issues here really
since 2020 up until today with where rates are and everything like that in the
interest rate side and bonds and the uncertainty around all that, but 60 -40, that’s
an asset allocation, or you could have a 50 -50, right? If you’re in your pre
-retirement stages of say you’re in your 20s to 50s, there is no one size fits all,
but in most cases, you’re going to be a little bit equity heavy because you really
want that growth, and you can handle the risk of the growth because you’ve got time
ahead of you, right? If you’re in your 20s, you’re probably not planning on retiring
until you’re in your 60s. You’ve got 40 years of growth and volatility that you can
handle. And the rule of thumb is as you get closer to retirement, you should be
reducing your equity exposure and increasing your safe exposure,
your fixed income type of exposure. Again, that’s a rule of thumb. We have clients
that are in their 70s and 80s that are a little bit more aggressive than some of
our clients that are in their early 50s. So, a bit of this is your appetite for
risk and how you approach it. But that’s really the idea is as we are younger and
we have time on our sides and earning and savings capability, we can be a little
bit heavier on the equity side. As we get retirement, you know, five years out,
three years out. There is a natural shift that happens in our own, in our own, uh,
behavioral side of things of, man, I’ve kind of got what I’ve got at this point.
Yeah, I’ll save a little bit more over the next few years, but this is it. And I
do want to retire and I do want to make this work. So, our behavior
starts to say, tell us that we need to have a shift, uh, in an overall investment
strategy. And it’s really having a plan in place so that when it comes time for
retirement, we know exactly the buckets that we’re going to be drawn off of. We
know what our exposure there is and everything like that. So, we fully believe when
it comes time for retirement and setting up an income plan, like Raiden said,
the buckets work really well. One, because it provides predictability, there’s this
thing called sequence of returns risk. So, imagine all your money is in the stock
market and you retire and then we walk into a 2008 type scenario or even more
recently here at 2022 type scenario where the markets were down 20 to 30%. All your
money is exposed to that. But also, on top of that, you need $5 ,000 a month out
of that portfolio. So, the market is losing money, which means your portfolio is
probably dropping as well as we are drawing on that money at the same time. That
is a scenario where it makes it really hard to recover from because we’re drawing
on it. That time horizon is now gone and we’re not putting money into it anymore.
So, segmenting our money to do different things for us at different times, that’s
what the buckets are. In our opinion, there’s two major buckets. You’ve got your
cash, that’s kind of your emergency cash reserve, but the two major investment
buckets are your income safety bucket and then your growth bucket. We want to have
good growth and we want to have long -term growth and that’s really the stock market
and tools within the stock market that are going to provide better returns over
time, but we don’t want to have to rely on the stock market for our monthly
paycheck. That’s why we allocate some of that money towards a safer bucket that is
not correlated to what the stock market is doing, that has protections in place that
we can’t lose money here, and also, it’s going to make us a decent rate of return,
bond like return or better than the bond market without the risk of the bond
market. So that now when we do retire and we do walk into a market downturn,
well, yeah, we may lose some money in the growth bucket, but our spending money is
preserved for a significant period of time. So, we’re taking our withdrawals from that
safety bucket. And now what we’ve done is we’ve bought time for the growth or the
stock market to recover. And so, to us, that’s really important to kind of optimize
our investment strategy, but also just make it so that we’re not so stressed about
the market every single day. And so that is something I think is what we coach on,
we’ve done several podcasts on, and we know it works very well. We see the
successes of it all the time. Is it the plan that’s going to make you hundreds of
very extreme high rates of returns in the ’20s and ’30s and ’40s? You may have a
year like that here and there, but that was for your ’20s, ’30s, and ’40s is to
make those types of rates of return because you could handle that risk. When we go
into post-retirement and spending that money, we want to grow, but we also want to
grow within reasons that we’re not uncomfortable with the amount of risk that we’re
taking. So, Radon, I know you were talking about some stories that you’ve got with
clients that have kind of gone through this, and let’s talk a little bit about
that. Real quick on this one is that we had a client, he came to us before he
was a client in 2007. Now if you remember, 2007 was the top of the big housing
boom. And when he came to us, he had retired from a company that he had an
executive pension and he had a base pension, and he had his social security was
going to be starting. So pretty much he said, hey, this sizeable 401k, that’s not
for me. That’s for the kids. I don’t need it. I’ve got more money coming in than
I can spend. Well, then came 2008. By the way, I’m sorry, he did become a client
And we did have a lot of conversations with him, and we did decide that we would
still do this bucket strategy. We would still put some money in places to keep him
secure and safe and be able to manage the risk. And then after becoming a client,
2008 hit, the market dropped considerably. Then came 2009 and the company that he
retired from filed bankruptcy. And when they filed bankruptcy, he lost his executive
pension. The base pension was covered by the federal government, the executive pension
was not, so he was back in the office saying, “Hey, I’m going to lose my executive
pension. Let’s come up. We’ve got to come up with an income plan now, because now
I don’t have enough coming in.” And I just wanted you to visualize how happy do
you think he was that we had put protection and risk management on that sizable 401
(k). And really, who got affected here in this deal? Really, the beneficiaries.
They’re not going to get as much, if they didn’t care that wasn’t their plan, the
parent’s plan was that they just needed to have a good plan in place. And the
kids, by the way, we know them still today, they were happy that mom and dad had
a good retirement. So that is the power of how we would shift pre -retirement to
during retirement. And just to wrap things up here really quick, Murs, if you just
want to let folks know here in the last couple of minutes what it is that they
need to make sure they’ve gotten place so that they understand exactly what they’ve
got. Yeah, so bringing this full circle, how do we put this into action? Well,
everything that we do, and we believe starts with this idea of a retirement focused
financial plan.