
Ep. 320
In this Episode of the Secure Your Retirement Podcast, Radon and Murs discuss the complexities of Inherited IRAs with special guest Taylor Wolverton, a Certified Financial Planner and Enrolled Agent. They break down what beneficiaries need to know about inherited retirement accounts, including crucial updates introduced under the Secure Act. Whether you’re a spouse, non-spouse, or special exception beneficiary, this episode helps you understand how to navigate the rules and avoid costly mistakes when it comes to inherited IRA distributions.
Listen in to learn about the different rules based on whether the account was inherited before or after 2020, how the 10-year rule inherited IRA provision works, and how it contrasts with the old Stretch IRA rules. They also explain IRA beneficiary rules for both Roth inherited IRA and traditional IRAs, helping you determine the most tax-efficient strategy for your situation. With insights on Inherited IRA RMD rules, Secure Act IRA changes, and options for non-spouse IRA beneficiaries, this is a must-listen episode for anyone dealing with an IRA inheritance.
In this episode, find out:
- What the 10-year rule inherited IRA really means for beneficiaries.
- How IRA rules for beneficiaries differ for pre- and post-2020 inheritances.
- The difference between spousal vs non-spouse IRA beneficiary strategies.
- How to handle Inherited IRA RMD rules and avoid tax penalties.
- Why Roth inherited IRA strategies may involve waiting until year 10.
Tweetable Quotes:
“Just because you’re not required to take a distribution every year doesn’t mean it’s the best strategy for your taxes.” – Murs Tariq
“Understanding whether you’re a spouse or non-spouse IRA beneficiary changes everything about how you manage the account.” – Taylor Wolverton
Resources:
If you are in or nearing retirement and you want to gain clarity on what questions you should be asking, learn what the biggest retirement myths are, and identify what you can do to achieve peace of mind for your retirement, get started today by requesting our complimentary video course, Four Steps to Secure Your Retirement!
To access the course, simply visit POMWealth.net/podcast.
Here’s the full transcript:
Welcome everyone to the Secure Your Retirement podcast. We’re excited that you’re
tuning in. We’ve got a great episode all around this concept of inherited IRA,
and the RMDs that we have to take on them, and there’s a lot of nuances to it.
There’s a lot of different rules. So, for that reason, we have brought in our very
own Taylor Wolverton, who is a certified financial planner, as well as an EA,
which is very similar to a CPA, so very well versed on tax. So, you take her
financial planning brain and her tax strategy and put that together, and we can
really talk through some cool things and come up with some great strategies. So
Taylor, thanks for hopping on with us today. – Yeah, you’re welcome. – So, like I
said, the concept of this episode today is really to inform people about inherited
IRAs and what we have to do to make sure we’re following the IRS’s rules. And the
big part of that is these required minimum distribution. So, while you are living and
you reach a certain age in your own IRA, typically that’s 73 or age 75,
you have what’s called a required minimum distribution. We’ve done episodes on that
before, so if you want to learn more about your own required minimum distribution
for your own IRA, check out that episode. So today is more focused on inherited IRA
RMDs. When you inherit it, you either inherited it from a spouse or a non -spouse
and both of those have different rules. And then to throw another wrench into it,
there were rule changes that happened in 2020. So, if it was prior to 2020 that you
inherited the IRA, there’s one set of rules. If you inherited the IRA after 2020,
there’s another set of rules. So clearly, it’s going to be a very fun episode and I’m
glad Taylor’s here to kind of walk us through. So, Taylor, let’s dive in on, let’s
start with what we would call the old rule, which is prior to 2020, if you
inherited an IRA, and let’s say for this one, a non -spouse. So, if you’re
listening, think you may be inherited an IRA from a sibling, or you inherited an IRA
from a friend or a family member, but a non -spouse, you are a non -spouse
beneficiary. What do we need to think about there, Taylor? – Yeah, so the rules, if
you were the non -spouse beneficiary of an IRA prior to 2020,
so, this is 2019 or earlier, the Secure Act is what changed these rules. So before
the rules changed, we referred to the way that inherited IRA distributions worked as
like a stretch IRA and that’s because the factors that determine your distribution
was the account balance the prior year and then also your life expectancy as the
beneficiary based on the IRS’s table that they publish it’s called the single life
expectancy table and so you could use your own life expectancy as the beneficiary,
it updates every single year as you go along and have that account, and it
basically, stretches out the distributions over your entire lifetime. So, if you
inherited an IRA from someone who was older than you, then it’s based on your life
expectancy, and now those distributions get stretched out over your life expectancy.
So, you have a longer amount of time than even the account the original account
owner would have to take those distributions. But like we said,
the Secure Act in 2019 changed those rules, eliminated the stretch IRA provision.
So now we have to accelerate our distributions, which is kind of what we’re going
to get into in this episode now. Yeah. So, and that’s a nice overview of the,
the old stretch IRA so when that went away in 2020, we had to adapt and by the
way if you’re listening you know and you’re taking RMDs on your own IRA well
the custodians and when I say custodians you can think of Charles Schwab or Fidelity
or Vanguard they have a responsibility to calculate what your own RMD is and they
report that to the IRS they also report it to you to make sure that you take what
you’re supposed to take out on your own IRA. With inherited IRAs though, because
there are so many nuances in the rules, they don’t calculate that for you, and they do
not remind you that you need to take it. So, I think it’s very important as we’re
kind of understanding these rules and very likely getting a little bit confused on
it, that it is important to work with someone That can help you stay on top of
your inherited IRAs as well as strategize around them as far as the distribution
goes and how it’s going to affect your financial plan and your tax plan as well.
So, I just wanted to throw that in there as you listen through this. And if you
have an inherited IRA and you need guidance; we’re always here for that. So, Taylor,
let’s talk about same category non -spouse beneficiaries that inherited their IRA in
January of 2020 or later. What does that look like now? – Yes, so,
and actually, too with the Secure Act, the reason why we’re having this conversation
now is even though these laws were announced in 2020, there’s been so much kind of
murkiness around the rules that the IRS has actually waived these requirements every
single year until five now. So, this is the first year that these rules actually
apply and are actually being enforced by the IRS because now they’ve clarified
exactly what we need to do to follow those rules and avoid penalties. So, if you
are a non -spouse beneficiary, so again, if you’re like the sibling of the original
account owner or the son, daughter, child, friend, neighbor, whatever it happens to
be, there are kind of two rules that we look at. The first one is the required
minimum distribution, the RMD. There’s potentially an RMD for your inherited IRA.
The second rule that will apply, I should say, is also the 10 -year rule.
So, like I said, the stretch IRA provision was 2019 and prior, spreading it out over
your entire lifetime, but now the IRS has asked us to accelerate those distributions
by enforcing the 10 -year rule. So, first kind of one that we’re looking at the RMD
applies if the original account owner was taking RMDs themselves.
So, if the person that you inherited the account from was 73 or older, they were
taking required minimum distributions themselves, they passed away. You inherited the
account, because the original owner was taking RMBs, you now as the beneficiary have
to also continue those RMBs. Regardless of your age as the beneficiary,
you have to continue the RMBs. And also, the 10 -year rule applies as well,
meaning you have to distribute the entire account balance by the 10th year after the
original owner passes away. So, we’re going to talk about a couple of examples to
show when certain rules apply and what that looks like and kind of on a timeline.
So, let me say that back to make sure that we’re on the same page here, Taylor.
So, let’s just assume that you inherited an IRA from a grandparent. And the
grandparent, well, let’s just say they were 80, so they were already in required
minimum distribution phase for themselves, they pass away, you inherit this account
and because they were taking required minimums, you have to continue taking required
minimums for them. There is a minimum amount that you have to take every year, but
also, there’s this caveat that you have to take all of the account out by the end
of the 10 years after you inherited it. So, in reality, when I think about that,
the minimum is not a tenth of the account every single year, the minimum’s much
less than that, so we need to be very strategic on how we’re going to clear out this
account, and definitely we don’t want that to sneak up on us. – Exactly, yes.
– Okay, so let’s go through some of the examples that you’ve got, and I’m sure I’ll
have questions there too. – Yeah, okay, so the rule that changes is the required
minimum distribution depending on the age that the original owner passed away. The 10
-year rule always applies. So, first example, let’s say there’s a beneficiary who
inherited an IRA. They’re 60 years old and they inherited it from their sibling who
was 65 at the time that they passed away. So, the sibling who passed away,
the original account owner was 65, that means they were not taking their own
required minimum distributions if they’re younger than age 73, which in this example
they are. So, there is no required minimum distribution for the inherited IRA owner
now as you as the beneficiary do not have to take distributions, but the 10 -year
rule does always apply regardless of the age of the original owner. So that means,
let’s say, the sibling who was the original account owner passed away last year in
2024. So now, as the beneficiary of the account, the beneficiary has 10 years to
empty that account altogether. So, by December 31, 2034, 10 years after the original
owner passed away, that account balance has to be zero. So, if they wanted to,
they could wait until December 31st, 2024, distribute the entire account balance at
that point in time. There are no penalties for not spreading it out over those 10
years. But the more tax -efficient way to do that is to spread it out over those
10 years rather than waiting until the final year where an entire distribution could
push you into a higher tax bracket. So even if there’s not a requirement to take a
distribution, it is so important to consider whether you want to take a distribution.
Even if the IRS is not forcing you to, there is still strategy involved in emptying
that account eventually. Right. And so, it requires kind of staying on top of it and
again, not letting it sneak up on you. The only way I could think it would make
sense to wait until the 10th year is if you are, in your example there, you’re 65
in this and maybe you’re still working and maybe you make a high salary. So maybe
you’re, what did you make 300 plus thousand a year and it’s a $100 ,000 IRA that
you inherited. Well, then it could make sense to wait until you did retire your
income drops and then you take significant distributions in those last couple of
years of the 10-year rule. I think that’s a rarity, but it is one that could
work, but I agree with you in most cases that makes sense to kind of spread it
out and take advantage of lowering.
beneficiary of this account again in 2024 is 60 years old. So now,
because the original account owner was 87, they were taking RMDs, the beneficiary now
as the owner of the
continue those RMDs, though we’re going to get a little more specific around what
that RMD is and how that gets calculated.
So, one important piece of information to know is the prior year account balance and
first let me say to in the year that the original owner passes away There’s not an
RMD for the inherited for the beneficiary the owner of the inherited IRA in the
year that the original owner passes away The RMD is based on their lifetime. So
it’s only the next year after their original owner passes away that the inherited
IRA RMD is enforced. So, in this example,
I’d say their original owner passes away in 2024. So now we’re in 2025. So the
first thing we need to know is the account balance the year prior. On December
31st of 2024, I’m just going to say in this example, the account balance was $50
,000. The other important factor to look at is now your life expectancy figure from
the IRS table. They call it the single life expectancy table. You base it on your
age as the beneficiary. So, in 2025, let’s say the beneficiary was age 61.
So, if you go and look at the IRS single life expectancy table for age 61, you’ll
see the life expectancy factor is 26 .2. So,
to figure out the required minimum distribution for 2025, we’re going to take the
$50 ,000 account balance, divide it by the life expectancy factor 26 .2,
and we’ll get the required minimum distribution for 2025 of around $1 ,908.
So that’s the minimum amount that has to come out of that account in 2025. But
again, the 10 -year rule also still applies, that account balance has to be zero by
December 31st of 2034. So again, it might make sense to strategize,
come up with a plan, look at your income for the next 10 years and figure out if
it’s worth taking more than the required minimum distribution or maybe you’re in a
situation where it doesn’t make sense. But either way, you want to know what those
rules are, what your R &D is, what your plan is, what the strategy is going to be
moving forward. And next year, I’ll say two, for going forward,
you still have the requirement of distribution every single year. But now you take
the life expectancy factor and you subtract one for every single year going forward.
So, the year starting the life expectancy factor in our example is 26 .2.
For next year, you’re going to subtract one and divide the account balance by 25 .2.
And then the year after 24 .2. So, you go back to the original age on the life
expectancy table for every single year of the calculation going forward. Got you. So
it’s a moving number is what I’m hearing year over year on the minimum calculation.
Now it just simple and easy math here. Let’s just say that every year our required
minimum is $2 ,000 a year and we’ve got a $50 ,000 account,
but if we’re only taking the 2 ,000 a year for the 10 years That’s 2 ,000 times
10. That’s 20 ,000. That’s been taken out We have to clean it out by year 10. And
so, there’s 30 ,000 left plus market growth So let’s just say there’s you know back
to somewhere in the realm of 50 ,000 because it continued to grow Now, we’ve got a
big distribution that we got to take by on that year 10. So that’s why, um, you
know, just sticking to the minimum may, may work for a little bit, but it could
come back to bite you if we don’t stay on top of it. Yes. Okay. So, what are some
exceptions to this 10-year rule? Um, and you know,
how, how’s all that work if we can still stretch it? Yeah. There are some
exceptions to where they can actually default back to the prior to secure act rules
with a stretch IRA. And that’s for the surviving spouse, or if you’re as the
beneficiary disabled or chronically ill, or minor children of the original account
owner, or if you’re the beneficiary less than 10 years younger than the original
account owner. So, I And with art, in my experience, those exceptions are also
pretty rare, but they do exist. So, it is important to note. Yeah. I think I’ve
seen one or two that fit the bill for the exception, but in most cases, you’re
going to the 10 -year rule. I mean, obviously the surviving spouse is probably the
most common exception. And that’s, you know, if my wife was to pass away,
I would inherit her IRA; that’s an exception to the 10 -year rule. So, let’s talk
about that, Taylor. Let’s talk about spousal beneficiaries that inherited in 2020 and
onwards. How does that work? Yes. Yeah. So, spouses have a little bit of different
rules that they’re allowed to follow, according to the IRS. So, one option that is
available to surviving spouses is to take that inherited IRA account balance and roll
it over into their own traditional IRA balance. What that does is allow you as the
surviving spouse to delay any RMDs until your own RMD age.
So, if I’m a spouse, I’m, let’s just say I’m 60 years old, my spouse passes There,
my spouse has a traditional IRA. I choose to take that option, rule my deceased
spouse’s IRA into my own account. And now I can delay my RMDs until I’m 73 or 75,
depending on your own RMD requirement for your age. So that allows you to delay
your RMDs rather than taking it when your spouse would have, according to their own
age. So that option makes sense, especially when you are the younger of your self
and your spouse to give you more time before you’re forced to take those
distributions. Yeah. And just in experience, I would say 90 % of the time,
we’re using that option, which is just to combine the seed and IRA with the as
IRA, just dump them together, and then now you’re under your own IRA rules, which
is the RMD later on in life. So that one makes it simple, it makes it easy, but
there are sometimes where we want to do something different, which is, as a
spouse, take it as an inherited IRA and not combine it with my own IRA.
Why would we ever choose that option? Yeah, that’s the other option, you can
maintain the account as an inherited IRA. For one, if you are the older spouse,
that can be a better move because then the RMDs will be based on the decedent,
their original owner spouse, their age. So, then I can give you as the surviving
spouse a little more time to delay rather than having to start at your own RMD
age, which would come sooner than your younger spouse. So, if you’re older, the older
of the spouses, it can make sense to go the inherited IRA route. And also,
if you are under the age of 59 and a half, it can make sense to make the account
into an inherited IRA because you can take distributions. Even if you’re under 59
and a half, you can take distributions from an inherited IRA without penalty, as
close to if you roll that account into your own traditional IRA, you’re underage
59 and a half, you cannot take distributions from your own traditional IRA when
you’re under age 59 and a half without penalty. So, if you want more flexibility in
having access to that money when you’re under 59 and a half, go the inherited IRA
route. Yeah, so age is going to be very important on a spousal beneficiary
election. So, this is all good and everything we’ve talked about so far has been
IRA, traditional IRA, pre -tax IRA, which means we haven’t paid a dime of taxes on
it yet. So, it goes without saying that when we’re taking these withdrawals it does
become taxable income and you are going to receive a 1099 for whatever RMD or RMD plus
additional that you decide to take is going to be taxable that year.
So that’s something we really need to think about as well in your tax strategy and
tax plan. But Taylor, let’s take a minute and talk about Roth IRAs. A lot of
people like the idea of a Roth, right? Roth conversions are a hot topic, funding
Roth 401Ks and IRAs because of this idea of future tax -free money and paying
the tax on that money now. So, it’s a great concept, but how do inherited Roths now
play into this whole conversation? – Yeah, I wanted to touch on Roth IRAs
specifically, because those rules are completely different. So, if you inherit a Roth
IRA, there is never a required minimum distribution. Regardless of the age of the
original account owner, you will not have an RMD as the beneficiary. However,
the 10 -year rule does still apply. So again, 10 years, December 31st,
10 years after the original owner passed away, that Roth IRA account balance must be
$0. But the logic for planning those distributions out over those 10 years is
different with the Roth IRA because unlike the traditional IRA, as if you leave your
Roth IRA invested, it continues growing through the future, then that growth is also
tax -free. So, what the Roth IRA can actually make sense to do the opposite and
leave that account balance for all 10 years where possible, because then you’ll have
a higher tax -free account balance in that 10th year and you can distribute it all
without any tax or penalty consequences in that 10th year. So, a little bit different
thought process with Roth IRAs because they are tax -free and have different benefits
than the traditional IRA. Yeah, I mean, think about that from a legacy planning
perspective. A lot of times when we have these conversations on Roth conversions, a
lot of times we’re doing conversions not necessarily for us, but we’re doing it for
our legacy and our inheritance so that they inherit money out as much of a tax
burden. So, if you think if we just put some simple numbers and easy numbers to it,
let’s say you leave behind $100 ,000 Roth IRA, someone inherits it.
And like Taylor said, there is no requirement of distribution. It still needs to be
cleared out by the year 10. But there’s no minimum that we have to take along the
way with the traditional IRA. We very likely don’t want to wait till year 10,
but excuse me, sorry, with the Roth IRA, we want to try to wait till year 10 as
much as possible, because take that 100 ,000 and it grows at a decent rate of
return in that 7 % -ish type of range over 10 years, that number is going to
double. So, 100 ,000 now becomes 200 ,000. And if we’re able to wait 10 years, now
we’ve got a bigger asset, which we can withdraw fully, completely tax -free. So, I
think that’s a pretty cool strategy to think about, which means we’ve got to educate
our beneficiaries a little bit or make sure that they’re working with the
professional as well. So, Taylor, this has been very insightful and very helpful.
Inherited IRAs are a little bit confusing, which again, I stress the reason to be
working with someone that understands them that can help you, kind of holistically
look at the best way to inherit and then make those distributions along the way. So
Taylor, thanks a lot for your time today. I’m sure everyone’s going to love this
episode. Yeah, you’re welcome. That was fun.