Retirement planning is a multifaceted and often complex process, especially when it comes to deciding the right age to start drawing Social Security benefits. This blog aims to dissect the pros and cons of taking Social Security at 62 versus waiting until 67, using insights from a detailed financial planning podcast discussion.

Introduction to the Decision

Retirement is a significant milestone, and deciding when to start drawing Social Security benefits is a critical part of that journey. Social security benefits can begin as early as age 62 or as late as age 70. The later the begin date, the higher the benefit amount. For that reason, the choice of when to begin benefits is a common dilemma faced by many. Each option has its own set of advantages and potential drawbacks, and the best choice depends on individual circumstances, financial goals, and life expectancy.

The Scenario

Let’s consider a scenario where a couple, Jim and Jane, are both 61 years old and planning to retire at 62. They each earn $150,000 per year, have prioritized saving for retirement, and as such, have managed to accumulate substantial assets in their retirement accounts. Their primary question is whether to start taking Social Security benefits at 62 or to live off their savings and wait until their full retirement age of 67.

Understanding Social Security Benefits

Social Security benefits are calculated based on your highest 35 years of earnings. The Social Security Administration (SSA) provides an online tool where individuals can view their estimated benefits at different retirement ages. For Jim and Jane, their estimated benefits at full retirement age (67) are $3,800 per month each.

Financial Considerations

1. Income Needs and Expenses: Jim and Jane’s current monthly expenses are $8,000, which includes living expenses, travel, and leisure activities. Their home is paid off, simplifying their financial needs somewhat.
2. Retirement Savings: Both have IRAs worth $750,000 each, making a total of $1.5 million in retirement savings. They are also contributing the maximum allowable amount to their 401(k) plans.
3. Social Security at 62 vs 67: If they start taking Social Security at 62, their benefits will be reduced by approximately 30%, resulting in around $2,660 per month each.

Analysis of Different Scenarios

Taking Social Security at 62

• Immediate Income: Starting benefits at 62 provides immediate income, reducing the need to draw down their retirement savings.
• Reduced Benefits: The benefits are reduced by 30%, impacting the total amount received over their lifetimes.
• Impact on Assets: By starting benefits early, Jim and Jane can preserve more of their retirement savings. However, the lower monthly benefits could result in less overall income if they live a long life.

Waiting Until 67

• Higher Monthly Benefits: Waiting until 67 increases their benefits to $3,800 per month each, providing a more substantial income.
• Drawdown of Assets: They will need to rely on their savings to cover expenses from 62 to 67. This could significantly deplete their retirement accounts.
• Long-Term Impact: Higher benefits from 67 onward can provide more financial security in later years, but this assumes they live long enough to benefit from the increased payments.

Detailed Financial Projections

Using financial planning software, we can project the impact of each option on Jim and Jane’s retirement assets:

1. Retiring at 62 and Taking Benefits at 62:
   • Initial drawdown from savings to supplement reduced Social Security benefits.
   • By age 90, their projected net worth is $3.1 million, assuming no major unforeseen expenses or market downturns.
2. Retiring at 62 and Waiting Until 67:
   • Larger drawdown from savings to cover expenses until 67.
   • By age 90, their projected net worth is $2.9 million, slightly less than if they had taken benefits at 62.
3. Waiting Until 70:
   • This option maximizes Social Security benefits but requires substantial drawdown from savings until benefits start.
   • By age 90, their projected net worth is $2.8 million, the lowest among the three options.

Holistic Approach to Decision Making

When deciding on the optimal age to start taking Social Security benefits, it is crucial to consider several factors:

1. Life Expectancy: If there is a family history of longevity, it might make sense to delay benefits to maximize lifetime income.
2. Current Health Status: Poor health might favor taking benefits earlier to ensure some benefits are received.
3. Retirement Lifestyle: Desired lifestyle and spending patterns during retirement play a significant role in this decision.
4. Tax Implications: Social Security benefits are taxable, and the timing of withdrawals can impact overall tax liability.
5. Other Income Sources: Availability of other income sources, such as pensions or rental income, can influence the decision.

Conclusion

The choice between taking Social Security at 62 versus waiting until 67 is not a one-size-fits-all decision. For Jim and Jane, starting benefits at 62 appears to be slightly more advantageous in terms of preserving their retirement assets. However, this decision is highly individualistic and should be made based on a comprehensive analysis of personal financial situations, health, and retirement goals.

Financial planning tools and consultations with financial advisors can provide valuable insights and help make an informed decision. Ultimately, the goal is to ensure a comfortable and secure retirement, with Social Security benefits complementing overall financial plans effectively.

For personalized advice and detailed financial planning, consider consulting with a retirement planning expert. Understanding the nuances of Social Security and integrating it into a broader financial plan can significantly impact the quality and security of your retirement years.

By considering the various factors and projections discussed, you can make a more informed decision about when to start taking your Social Security benefits. This comprehensive analysis should help you weigh the pros and cons and choose the best path for your unique situation.

If you want to understand all this a little better, we offer a complimentary phone call that you can schedule with us on our website. If we can’t answer all your questions in just 15 minutes, we’ll guide you to the next steps to find the answers you need.

Schedule your complimentary call with us and to learn more about holistic wealth management.